Generally Football
This article is written by my Australian friend Peter Upham. Peter owns Shire Speed and Strength but also has coached, played, and S&C coached American style football for many years. He’s a student of sport history and loves talking about the theory behind training. Two of his kids have received scholarships to play at the University of Hawaii, and that’s where our journey begins.
GENERALLY FOOTBALL
by Peter Upham
Its playoff time for the NFL, College Football has reached its climax, and so as we have just bypassed the Perihelion (the furthest point from the Sun of the Earth’s orbit), those players are also the furthest point from football summer camps and the heat of preseason training.
An athlete does not just ‘do’ their sport. The athlete, does what is necessary to enhance their general abilities whilst they continue to master the technical-tactical skills of their game. For football, like most sports, this was not always the case.
In 1976, Terry Albritton would set the world record in the shot put at the University of Hawaii’s Cooke Field in an all-comer’s meet. The same year, Bill Starr published ‘The Strongest Shall Survive.’ Bill was the Strength and Conditioning coach at Hawaii and would hand over the job eventually to Albritton. Previous to that, he had been the Strength and Conditioning coach for the Baltimore Colts.
CLICK TO
Hawaii would become a hotbed of strength training activity. It was the training base for the 1977 IPF World Powerlifting Championships before the team headed to Perth, Australia; the SHW division won by 70’s Big co-captain Doug Young. It was the location of the first 700lb bench press in competition by Ted Arcidi in 1985 at the Budweiser World Record Breakers and the second ever 900lb deadlift by Doyle Kenady. Jim ‘The Anvil’ Neidhart, who was a very competitive thrower before turning to the WWF and ‘The Hart Foundation’, spent time there training; a peer of Albritton’s. The place was not the barbell Mecca of Dayton, Ohio or Venice Beach but it has its place.
The book, was and is, a compendium and anthology of barbell training for football preparation. It was published at a time when strength training for football required a concerted push. Coaches were still largely fixed in the ‘barbells = big/bulky/slow athletes’ epoch, and Starr’s book provided a definitive text that outlined the lifting skills and programming with football players in mind. It also advised on diet, and 5 editions later you’ll still hear it referenced in S&C circles for football preparation.
The Strongest Shall Survive promoted ‘The Big Three’; Squat, Bench and Power Clean. Here was a simple prescription, a 5×5 arrangement of Light, Medium and Heavy alternating lifts. It pictorially explained the lifts and described their use and implementation. Its usefulness set it as the gold standard for many years and it’s rightfully known as a classic.
Starr’s book was written for the very large football population, but the exercise prescriptions in it are general training. Did it mean that if you’re doing ‘The Big Three’, that you were preparing for a football season? Of course not, we know what an obviously fatuous observation that would be, but what about the corollary? Do I need to do those lifts to prepare for football?
There are 3 main influences for exercise prescription; Therapy, Commercialism and Performance. In sport, Performance should be the main influence but there’s gold-in-them-thar-hills! And if you can appear to be providing some sort of elite specialization, then there is a large population out there willing to listen to you and be separated from their money to reach their goals. People prefer it if they feel like a unique special snowflake and the S&C coach wants his team to be taking the shortest cut to better physical abilities. So General preparation has, by Commerical interest, become muddled and rail-roaded into a specialized endeavour.
The football player has a grueling calendar. For large parts of the year, both in competition season and in the Spring practice period, technical-tactical training must be given precedence. Additionally, the fatigue of this practice makes progress in the development of general capacities like strength impossible for anyone but the novice/low intermediate athlete. This leaves us with shortened periods to enhance General capacities like strength, speed (in the main movement pattern running), agility, flexibility and so on.
If the football player is only able to use two blocks of time for the development of general capacities then can he afford for it to be complex?
The strongest and most powerful athletes, those who can move more weight further with less support and in less time, have relatively simple exercise prescriptions that only vary by load. Find a Powerlifter or Olympic lifter and they basically do a few things; but do them really, really well. An Olympic Lifter will Front Squat, Back Squat, Clean, Snatch, Jerk and do some pull ups. Exercise variety usually comes in the form of components of those lifts. It is not unusual however to see vastly complex prescriptions being given to football players.
What would happen if you had athletes who only had a couple of short training blocks in a year, who were asked to implement the entire realm of Commercial interest exercise prescription? Flyes and cables and presses and swings and lunges and jumps and twists? and Lions and Tigers and Bears oh my!
Well you’d end up with barbell mechanics like this (how are these PR’s quantified with the hands of 6 spotters on the bar?).
And this (WTF is a ‘Whip Snatch’? Isn’t that what you wouldn’t want to do?).
And this (how about the mental toughness to ‘master’ those few barbell lifts you give lip service to pal?).
And these are by no means the most egregious. I leave it to the fair-mindedness of the reader; does a football player who cannot squat to a legal IPF depth really need to worry about Bulgarian split squats and box squats with bands and chains?
It seems to me that if you can snatch, you don’t have mobility problems. If you can squat 400lb you don’t have weak legs. If you can deadlift 500lb you don’t have a weak posterior chain, you can’t! But browse the uploads of just about any football program and honestly, do you see barbell competence? Those numbers are not exceptional at all but how many football players can actually do it? If we matched the genetic potential of the talent pool with proper coaching we’d have a lot better result than 500lb quarter squats and 105lb power snatches with a clean grip.
Bill Starr’s book shows the complexity is in the movement pattern, NOT in the prescription. I have always found that it’s more a case of leaving things out than including more in a program when it comes to athletes. Starr’s prescription leaves out the deadlift; a known stressor that the football player may leave out so he may get through his important technical-tactical training without that extra fatigue to adapt to. This is an omission worth noting.
Training, for the general strength trainer, the recreational strength trainer and the competitive strength trainer starts with the mastery of what works for all athletes and evolves through the variance of resistance, not with variance of selection.
The Hawaii story brings this article full circle for me. I have been fortunate enough to send 2 players to play football at Hawaii, and I hope in the future there will be more. Its unusual and notable because, coming from Australia, this doesn’t happen very often. In fact, those two are the only two who have ever played locally and then gone straight to play at a FBS school on scholarship; and they’re not punters! We’re slowly taking your game over, and no, the irony of an Australian writing on a US based website about football is not lost on me. The BCS Championship game has an Australian on each roster, and although we’re mostly punters, we’re just starting at the bottom and working our way up to total domination.



January 10th, 2012 at 1:36 pm
Could you imagine dropping Barwis for that new Michigan S&C program?
January 10th, 2012 at 2:14 pm
Where can I find a copy of “The Strongest Shall Survive?”
Amazon has it new for $100.
January 10th, 2012 at 2:21 pm
@Ron: http://aasgaardco.com/store/store.php?crn=199&rn=295&action=show_detail
January 10th, 2012 at 2:32 pm
20 word or less summary.
Barbell lift technique is important, a few australians play american football at the college level, bill starr is kind of neat.
January 10th, 2012 at 2:32 pm
As a slow guy who squats 300 lbs. in his garage, I hate to armchair quarterback these coaches. But it’s hard not to when these videos all show such stupid shit. It’s just unreal.
January 10th, 2012 at 2:32 pm
It’s amazing what an undeserved/inflated sense of confidence can achieve. These Div. I “strength coaches” can speak confidently and intelligently enough to buffalo the layperson but don’t understand basic barbell mechanics (not to mention allow partial/assisted reps in order to obfuscate actual results).
Good post. Fitness is in a strange position right now.
January 10th, 2012 at 2:35 pm
Related and possibly intersting for some people: I’m a Johns Hopkins alumnus. While I was in school I had a campus job checking IDs in the varsity weight room for two years. I witnessed a LOT of silly bullshit and excessive “complexity” like ab crunch interval training and decline, incline and flat bench circuits, 1/4 squats, dumbell shrugs with a rolling/rotating shoulder joint (ouch!), etc. I could go on and on about this. Last year, I ran into the current lacrosse coach, who was also the coach when I was in school. In fairness they did win the championship during that time, but they also had exceptional recruiting and lost the other three years. I asked him if he was on the coaching staff at the same time as Bill Starr. He said he pushed Starr out because all he seemed to care about was making the lacrosse players into weight lifters, implying that they would be slow and musclebound. I wasn’t going to tell a champion how to do his job, so I didn’t say anything else, but I did find it very telling that he clearly had a disdain for heavy weight training.
January 10th, 2012 at 3:15 pm
Maslow: As you indicated, winning one championship in four years at Hopkins is nbd. There are like six D1 teams that even compete, and Hopkins has more tradition than any of them save maybe Syracuse. In short, as awesome as Pietramala is lacrosse-wise, it sounds like he was ignorant in this instance.
January 10th, 2012 at 3:26 pm
[...] My article is up over at 70′s Big. [...]
January 10th, 2012 at 3:36 pm
As a fan of Big 10 Football, I’m pretty disappointed.
January 10th, 2012 at 3:55 pm
@Justin and anyone. A guy at my gym yesterday was asking me if I could remember the names of any of the big powerlifters from the 80s. He was specifically wondering about the one (or more?) who switched over to pro wrestling. Any idea who he’s thinking of?
January 10th, 2012 at 4:18 pm
SEC > other teams mentioned so far.
January 10th, 2012 at 4:28 pm
I went to a junior coaching clinic (AFL) and had to listen to the lecturer telling everyone that weights hurt kids growth plates and only makes them slow and muscle-bound anyway.
FWIW I was discussing lifting with a pro football S&C coach (rugby league). Bench, squat, press and weighted chins (he loves these for footballers) were his prescription. Deadlifting is only done out of season due to the amount of work footballers’ lower backs get. His in-season programming was somewhat similar to 5/3/1.
Oh and as a Brisbane boy… Go Tide!
January 10th, 2012 at 4:32 pm
@Maslow. You might be talking about Ken Patera.
January 10th, 2012 at 7:21 pm
Peter, great article. It is right on point. I am finishing an exercise physiology degree and doing a S&C internship with a major division one school. The complexity of the program our players are put through leaves no time for them to learn the technical aspects of the barbell lifts. Also, what isn’t mentioned in most of those videos is that a players 1RM is based off of the NSCA’s rep max formulas and charts. No 1RM’s are ever done. There are a lot of 400 lb. power cleans on our board, but I have yet to see anyone I thought could actually pull that.
January 10th, 2012 at 8:44 pm
What/How is the Dayton, Ohio barbell Mecca you speak of? Just curious…
January 10th, 2012 at 9:47 pm
I have nothing useful to say about training football players, and I appreciate simplicity in programming, but in my own experience getting to 400 squat / 500 deadlift was NOT a guarantee of strong legs and posterior chain. What that did was expose weaknesses (especially back / hamstrings) that the competition lifts were not addressing. Special exercises like glute ham raises, dimel deadlifts, and, most of all, reverse hypers, were and are humbling in this respect. Bands and to a lesser extent box squat variations also filled some gaps.
January 10th, 2012 at 10:46 pm
Good article and congrats. As a small nitpick, the Perihelion is the closest point to the Sun in the Earths orbit.
January 11th, 2012 at 8:04 am
Those videos were pretty bizarre. Whip Snatch? C’mon now…
January 11th, 2012 at 8:05 am
@Maslow… are you thinking of Ted Arcidi
January 11th, 2012 at 8:20 am
Thanks hawkpeter and bohdi! There may be others but those guys certainly were weight lifters before they entered professional wrestling. Another guy I found is Jim “The Anvil” Neidhart. He was a thrower/weight lifter before entering the world of wrestling.
January 11th, 2012 at 9:29 am
Why would a football training “gym” have so many inflatable exercise balls? Looked like a geriatric rehab center.
January 11th, 2012 at 9:41 am
“The mass of mankind… never assents long to any one remedy, but is always best pleased by a novelty which has not yet proved illusory.” -Spinoza
January 11th, 2012 at 11:03 am
Just a heads up, I bet 5 doll hairs that the reason whip snatches are in these people’s programs is because Dan John has mentioned them in several of his articles over the years.
January 11th, 2012 at 11:37 am
5 doll hairs, damn you must be serious bro.
January 12th, 2012 at 8:20 am
[...] “And if you can appear to be providing some sort of elite specialization, then there is a larg… – From 70sBig post. Don’t get caught up in the hype of hot new exercises, do what works and reap all the results. Filed under: CrossFit Vernon Comment (0) [...]